There are days when I can recognize a stressful thought and choose not to follow it. On other days, the same thought keeps returning, no matter how much I would prefer to feel differently.
That experience led me to an intriguing question: Can we really decide how we feel?
Metacognition offers a useful way to explore the answer. Often described as thinking about your thinking, it involves noticing, evaluating, and sometimes adjusting your own mental processes.
However, metacognition does not give anyone a switch that turns off anxiety, sadness, anger, or grief. Its practical value lies in recognizing what is happening and considering what to do next.
I wanted to understand what research actually supports. So I examined studies of emotional awareness, psychological distancing, the brain, cognitive behavioral therapy, and metacognitive learning.
Quick Summary: What Metacognition Can and Cannot Do
- Metacognition means awareness and regulation of thinking. It includes noticing what you know, recognizing uncertainty, and evaluating the strategies you use.
- Emotional awareness can create options. Noticing a feeling may help you choose a response, even if the feeling does not immediately change.
- Psychological distancing has research support. Viewing a thought or situation from another perspective can reduce emotional intensity in some settings.
- Naming a feeling is not a guaranteed fix. Its effects vary, and recent research suggests that labeling can sometimes interfere with a later reappraisal exercise.
- The brain relies on multiple networks. Metacognition and emotion regulation cannot be reduced to strengthening one part of the prefrontal cortex.
- Structured treatments are different from self-help. Metacognitive therapy and cognitive behavioral therapy have clinical research behind them; a brief check-in is not a substitute.
- More monitoring is not always better. Repeated self-checks can become burdensome for some people, particularly when they turn into rumination.
- The useful goal is flexibility. You do not have to feel calm before taking a thoughtful, constructive action.
What Is Metacognition?
Metacognition is the ability to think about and evaluate your own thinking.
For example, I might notice that I do not understand something I am reading. Instead of continuing automatically, I can slow down, look up a term, and check my understanding.
That is metacognition in action.
It also appears when I recognize that I am making an assumption, overestimating my certainty, or repeating an unhelpful thought.
However, not every moment of self-awareness is a deliberate attempt to change something.
Sometimes, noticing a mental process is useful on its own. At other times, I need to evaluate whether a different strategy would serve me better.
The Two Main Parts of Metacognition
Metacognitive Knowledge
Metacognitive knowledge involves understanding something about your own thinking.
I might know that I remember information better when I test myself instead of repeatedly rereading it.
Or I might recognize that I tend to interpret a delayed reply as rejection when I am already stressed.
This knowledge does not mean my interpretation is always wrong. However, it gives me a reason to examine it before acting.
Metacognitive Monitoring and Regulation
Monitoring involves checking what is happening in my thinking. Regulation involves deciding whether to continue, change strategies, or seek help.
During a difficult task, I might ask whether my approach is working.
During an emotional moment, I might ask whether I am reacting to what happened or to a prediction I have made about it.
In both cases, I am using awareness to inform my next step.
Can Metacognition Help You Decide How You Feel?
Not in the literal sense of choosing any emotion on command.
Feelings arise from interacting processes involving the brain, body, memories, circumstances, and other factors.
I cannot reasonably expect someone experiencing grief, panic, chronic stress, or a major life disruption to simply decide to feel happy.
However, people sometimes have more influence over their response than they initially notice.
For example, I may not be able to prevent the first surge of frustration. Yet I might recognize it before sending an angry message.
That pause creates an opportunity to choose whether to respond immediately, ask a question, or return to the conversation later.
The distinction matters: I may not control the arrival of a feeling, but I can sometimes change my relationship to it and my behavior afterward.
The Science of Psychological Distancing
Psychological distancing involves viewing an emotional experience from a different perspective.
Instead of experiencing every thought as a direct statement of fact, I can recognize it as something my mind is producing.
For example, consider the thought, “I am going to fail.”
I might respond by noticing, “I am having the thought that I might fail.”
The second statement does not prove that I will succeed. However, it helps distinguish a prediction from a fact.
A review and neuroimaging meta-analysis of psychological distancing found support for distancing as an emotion-regulation strategy.
However, the researchers also described uncertainty about its precise mechanisms and how laboratory findings apply across situations.
Does Saying “I Am Having the Thought” Actually Help?
That phrase is an example of stepping back from a thought rather than treating it as a command.
Related approaches appear in psychological distancing and acceptance-based therapies.
However, changing one sentence is not a guaranteed treatment.
A useful experiment is to notice whether the phrasing gives me enough space to choose my next action.
If it does, I can use it. If it becomes another rule I feel compelled to perform perfectly, I can stop.
The purpose is flexibility, not replacing every uncomfortable thought with a more acceptable sentence.
Does Naming an Emotion Change the Brain?
Researchers call the practice of putting feelings into words affect labeling.
In a well-known brain-imaging study, people labeled emotional images while researchers measured brain activity.
Compared with certain other tasks, labeling was associated with lower activity in the amygdala and greater activity in a region of the prefrontal cortex.
These findings suggest that language can influence emotional processing.
However, they do not demonstrate that naming a feeling switches off the amygdala or guarantees relief in daily life.
Read the affect-labeling brain-imaging study.
Why More Emotional Awareness Is Not Always Better
I once assumed that naming a feeling could only help. The research is more complicated.
A newer study compared emotion labeling, reappraisal, their combination, and passive observation while participants viewed negative images.
In those experiments, labeling reduced the effectiveness of subsequent reappraisal.
That finding does not mean people should stop identifying their emotions.
Instead, it shows why I should avoid treating every self-awareness technique as universally helpful.
Read the study examining affect labeling and reappraisal together.
A practical approach is to notice what happens next. If a brief label helps me respond constructively, I can use it. If repeatedly naming the emotion keeps me stuck, I can try another approach.
How Is Metacognition Different From Cognitive Restructuring?
Metacognition means noticing and evaluating thinking. Cognitive restructuring is a more specific process used in cognitive behavioral therapy, or CBT.
In cognitive restructuring, a person examines the evidence for a troubling interpretation and develops a more balanced view when appropriate.
For example, suppose I think, “One mistake proves I am incompetent.”
Metacognition helps me notice that I am making a broad judgment from one event.
Cognitive restructuring asks me to examine the evidence and consider whether a more accurate interpretation is possible.
That might lead to, “I made a mistake, and I can identify what to improve.”
However, the purpose is not to force a positive thought when there is a real problem to address.
The National Institute of Mental Health explains how CBT addresses thoughts, emotions, and behavior.
How Is Metacognition Different From Mindfulness?
Mindfulness commonly involves paying attention to present experience with less automatic judgment.
Metacognition is broader. It includes monitoring learning, evaluating confidence, planning, and regulating thought processes.
The two can overlap when I notice that my mind has wandered or that I am reacting automatically.
However, they are not identical methods, and neither requires me to stop having unwanted thoughts.
For a related science discussion, read my article on what a short meditation study actually found about the brain.
What Happens in the Brain During Metacognition?
The prefrontal cortex is important in many forms of planning, monitoring, and cognitive control.
However, it does not work alone.
Neuroscience research links metacognitive and emotion-regulation tasks with distributed networks that can involve frontal, parietal, and other brain regions.
Different tasks recruit different patterns of activity.
Therefore, I would not claim that a few daily check-ins automatically strengthen specific neural pathways or give someone greater executive control.
Brain-imaging studies can identify associations. They do not, by themselves, prove that a simple self-help exercise produces lasting structural changes.
The neurocognitive review of distancing describes a more complex model involving self-reflection and cognitive control.
What Is Metacognitive Therapy?
Metacognitive therapy, often abbreviated MCT, is a structured psychological treatment.
It is not the same as casually noticing thoughts or setting reminders on a phone.
MCT examines patterns such as persistent worry, rumination, and beliefs about the usefulness or danger of thinking.
For example, a person may believe that worrying constantly is the only way to prevent a bad outcome.
Treatment may help the person reconsider that belief and change how much time they spend engaging with worry.
However, techniques should be matched to the person and their clinical needs by an appropriately trained professional.
What Do Clinical Studies Say About Metacognitive Interventions?
A systematic review and meta-analysis examined randomized trials of metacognitive therapy and metacognitive training in adults with psychiatric disorders.
The researchers analyzed 49 studies involving 3,239 participants.
They found promising results for both types of intervention compared with several control conditions.
However, the authors identified limitations involving study reporting and methods. They called for better-quality trials.
Read the systematic review of metacognitive interventions.
For me, the main lesson is that a structured therapy can have meaningful clinical research without proving that an informal self-monitoring exercise treats the same conditions.
Metacognition for Learning and Problem-Solving
Emotions drew me to this topic, but metacognition has an important role in learning as well.
Before studying something difficult, I can ask what I already know and what I need to learn.
During the task, I can check whether I understand it or am merely recognizing familiar words.
Afterward, I can test myself and adjust my approach.
Researchers often describe this process as planning, monitoring, and evaluating.
The Education Endowment Foundation’s evidence review supports explicitly teaching these strategies within real learning tasks.
However, educational outcomes should not be treated as proof that the same exercises cure anxiety or depression.
A Practical Metacognition Exercise: Notice, Name, Choose
The original article suggested checking in with your feelings every hour. I would make that idea more flexible.
Some people may find brief reflection useful. Others may become more preoccupied with their feelings when asked to monitor them repeatedly.
Therefore, I would begin with one optional check-in at a natural point in the day rather than setting an alarm that interrupts every hour.
Step 1: Notice What Is Happening
I might ask, “What am I noticing in my thoughts, feelings, and body right now?”
I do not need to search for the perfect description. A simple observation is enough.
For example, I may notice that I am frustrated, my shoulders feel tense, and I keep replaying a conversation.
Step 2: Separate the Feeling From the Story
Next, I can distinguish the emotion from my interpretation.
“I feel worried” describes an experience. “Something terrible is definitely going to happen” is a prediction.
However, I do not need to dismiss a legitimate concern. Some worries point to problems that deserve practical action.
Step 3: Choose One Useful Response
I might decide to clarify a misunderstanding, complete one small task, take a break, or seek support.
Sometimes, the useful response is to allow an uncomfortable feeling to remain while I continue with something important.
The goal is not to make myself feel different immediately. It is to choose a response that fits the situation.
Step 4: Check Whether the Exercise Helps
Later, I can ask whether the check-in helped me act with greater clarity.
If it did, I may use it again.
If it increased anxiety, consumed too much time, or turned into repeated self-criticism, I can stop or use a different strategy.
There is no requirement to monitor every feeling throughout the day.
Why Constant Self-Monitoring Can Become Rumination
Metacognitive awareness and rumination are different.
Awareness helps me recognize a thought and assess what to do next. Rumination can involve repeatedly circling the same concern without reaching a useful response.
For example, noticing “I am worried about tomorrow” may help me prepare.
Repeatedly asking why I am worried, whether I should be worried, and whether I have stopped worrying can leave me more entangled in the feeling.
A systematic review of mood-monitoring studies reported that some participants experienced stress or mood worsening.
However, the review could not establish that monitoring caused those effects.
That uncertainty is a good reason to make self-checks optional and responsive to how the person experiences them.
Can Metacognition Help With Anxiety?
Noticing worry patterns can be part of a helpful treatment plan.
However, anxiety disorders involve more than an ordinary stressful thought.
Someone with persistent anxiety may need evidence-based psychotherapy, medication, or both, depending on their circumstances.
The National Institute of Mental Health describes established approaches for generalized anxiety disorder, including CBT and other treatments.
I would not tell someone that ongoing anxiety means they have failed to practice metacognition correctly.
Nor would I claim that observing thoughts is a replacement for professional care.
Can Metacognition Help With Depression?
Self-awareness may help someone recognize patterns in mood, thinking, and activity.
However, depression is not simply a habit of choosing the wrong thoughts.
A person cannot reliably reason themselves out of depression through willpower alone.
Research supports structured psychological treatments for many people, and medication or other care may also be appropriate.
The National Institute of Mental Health explains treatment options for depression.
If symptoms persist or interfere with daily life, I would encourage an assessment rather than another round of unstructured self-monitoring.
Can Metacognition Help With Stress-Related Muscle Tension?
Stress can affect breathing, sleep, attention, and the way muscle tension feels.
For example, I might not notice that I have been holding my shoulders up while concentrating.
A brief check-in could help me recognize that posture and decide to move, rest, or change position.
However, noticing tension does not establish its medical cause.
Persistent pain or other concerning symptoms may require assessment, especially when they do not respond to ordinary changes in activity.
For more on how bodily symptoms and psychological processes can interact without making pain imaginary, read my article on mind-body pain and what the science says.
Where Does Massage Fit Into This Discussion?
As a massage therapist, I work with people who want help with muscular discomfort, recovery, and relaxation.
Some clients find that a comfortable massage session allows them to notice how their body feels.
However, I do not describe massage as metacognitive therapy, psychotherapy, or a treatment that rewires the emotional-control centers of the brain.
Those would be unsupported claims.
For someone seeking bodywork in Santa Barbara, my deep tissue massage and therapeutic sports massage services address physical comfort and movement-related concerns when appropriate.
I can adjust pressure and technique to the person. However, massage does not replace mental-health treatment or medical evaluation.
Frequently Asked Questions About Metacognition and Emotions
What is metacognition in simple terms?
It means noticing and evaluating your own thinking. You might recognize an assumption, check your understanding, or decide to change an unhelpful strategy.
Can I choose how I feel?
Not completely. You may be able to influence some emotional responses, but feelings are not always under voluntary control. You can sometimes choose what to do while a feeling is present.
Does naming an emotion reduce its intensity?
Sometimes, but not reliably in every situation. Laboratory studies have found changes in emotional processing, while other studies show that labeling can interact with later regulation strategies in complicated ways.
Is metacognition the same as mindfulness?
No. They overlap, but metacognition also includes planning, evaluating confidence, monitoring learning, and adjusting thinking strategies.
Is metacognitive therapy the same as CBT?
No. They are different structured treatment approaches, although both address patterns of thinking and behavior.
Should I set an alarm to check my emotions every hour?
There is no established requirement to do that. An occasional brief check-in may be more practical. If monitoring makes you more distressed or preoccupied, stop and reconsider the approach.
Does metacognition strengthen the prefrontal cortex?
Research links metacognitive tasks to activity across several brain networks. It does not establish that a simple daily exercise reliably strengthens one brain region or produces lasting structural changes.
Can metacognition replace therapy for anxiety or depression?
No. Structured therapies may use metacognitive skills, but an informal exercise is not a substitute for evaluation or treatment when symptoms persist or disrupt daily life.
The Bottom Line
Metacognition gives me a useful way to notice how I am thinking and decide whether my current approach is helping.
It may also create space between an emotion and my next action.
However, that is different from having the power to choose every feeling.
The research supports psychological distancing in some situations, structured metacognitive interventions in clinical settings, and explicit metacognitive strategies for learning.
At the same time, the evidence does not justify promising that an hourly feelings alarm will rewire the brain or treat a mental-health condition.
My practical takeaway is simple: I can notice a thought, recognize a feeling, and ask what response would be useful. I do not need to eliminate the feeling first.
For me, that is a more realistic form of agency than trying to control every emotion.
If you are in Santa Barbara and would like an in-call massage for muscular tension or physical recovery, I welcome you to my downtown PRO Massage studio. My massage services are separate from the psychological research discussed in this article.
Book an in-call massage appointment in Santa Barbara.
In-Call Massage Only @ my Artistic PRO Sports Massage Studio @ 827 State St., Suite 20, Text ONLY for appointments: 805-637-7482
Riktr PRO Massage: Injury Recovery
Standard Mon - Fri: $150/hr
(Save $45 - Mon-Fri)
Weekends & Holidays: $175/hr
📍 827 State St, Suite 20, SB 93101
View on Google MapsFirst-time clients: A $25 deposit is required to hold your appointment time and is applied to your session.
Book Online NowOr Text: 805-637-7482
Location and Reviews
Find PRO Massage on Google Maps

*Disclaimer:
This information is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. This is not medical advice, and you should always consult your primary care doctor or a qualified healthcare provider regarding any specific health problem or disease. Nearly 2 decades of therapeutic bodywork experience provide a clinical perspective, but individual results may vary, and specific outcomes are not guaranteed. Clinical bodywork involves intense physical manipulation; it is the reader’s responsibility to ensure they are healthy enough for such activity and to disclose all medical conditions to their provider. The decision to act on any information provided is the sole responsibility of the reader. All trademarks and brand names referenced are the property of their respective owners.
